Why Can't I Be You?
This past week I discovered that I actually have the MTV Canada channel, so being curious I decided to spend some time sifting through the entertaining trash that's being aired on that channel.
In between sneak peaks of the new season of Laguna Beach 3 and The Real World in Las Vegas, I stumbled upon a particularly appalling show called "Why Can't I Be You?".
The concept behind "Why Can't I Be You?" is that most people don't like who they are, and in fact wish they had someone else's life. This show gives people (usually so-called nerds or socially awkward individuals) the chance to be "mentored" for 48 hours by the person they most want to be like. Now, I'm all down for being mentored and learning how to cultivate certain characteristics that one lacks (like patience for example), but that is definitely not the approach the MTV execs wanted to take with this show. Instead of learning how to follow in the footsteps of someone who's a humanitarian or even tempered or virtuous in any other way, the people featured on "Why Can't I Be You ?" are trying to be like people who are "smooth with the ladies", "not afraid of what anyone thinks about them" (which was the best episode I saw, although it had it's fair share of shallow elements), and " a man's man".
I can't believe that a show like this actually exists! I couldn't stop laughing while I watched it because I was in utter shock that something like this can be aired. What ever happened to being the best "you" that you can be, with developing your skills and abilities until you reach your full potential?
But I guess I shouldn't really be surprised. In our culture where we are eager to remodel everything from buildings to our bodies, it's no surprise that people want to remodel their personalities. "Why Can't I Be You?" is like "The Swan", except it focuses on remodelling people's souls instead of their bodies. I guess what upset me the most about this show isn't so much that the people featured in the episodes wanted to "remodel" their personalities, but more so that they had the attitude that certain attributes (like certain body shapes) were more desirable than others, and that "undesirable" attributes like shyness had no value whatsoever in their world and were something to be disposed of. Now don't get me wrong, I think there are certain attitudes like self-entitlement and bigotry that our world is certainly better off without, but people aren't born with those characteristics, rather they learn over time that those are "acceptable" ways of being in the world. No, what I am outraged at is that there are guys out there who are shy and actually respectful of women but think that there is something wrong or deficient with that, and instead want to learn how to be a players (aka: smooth with the ladies)who have no problems peddling themselves on women. But more than being outraged at people who don't have enough respect for themselves to want to be themselves, I am completely and utterly outraged at MTV and the broader North American culture that it reflects for believing and spreading the idea that who you are is inferior or some how deficient if it doesn't match up to what the ideal man or woman should be like, and goes ahead to applaud those who abandon their true identities to become a clone of someone else.
That's not to say that everyone probably has one or two or more traits that they wish they had or would like to cultivate in themselves, but I would hope that those traits would enhance who they are already instead of oblitterating their unique personality completely.
Why can't you be yourself and be happy with that? Why should you think that there is something so wrong with you that you need to be like someone else? I hope these questions cause you to think about your own perception of yourself and the messages that are constantly being sent at us about how we should be. If you've seen the show let me know what you think of it.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home